45 years of Reaganism not only led to record income inequality (worse than even Robber Baron days and worse than any industrialized nation, even Great Britain), but also a flip in income's age distribution. Partly due to indexing Social Security, already the most regressive public pension plan on Earth (Reverse Robin Hood: transfers income from working poor with low life expectancy to long-lived middle class elderly who need supplements least). At the same time, vanishing union power (Reagan's and corporate war on unions, reclassification of workers into temps, "associates," adjuncts, intern trainees, independent contractors who can't be organized), discriminated women and minority domination of wage-earners, migration to anti-union Sunbelt, gutting of worker protections, and U.S. shift from shortest to longest workweeks with fewest vacation day (while most nations have early retirement for heavy-labor workers!
But Dems losses in 5 out of 6 presidential elections caused Dems, to tack to the center-right (as if more voters would ever opt for Republican-lite over "principled", , real conservatives who'd never "sell out" -- i.e., never compromise their simplistic government-the-source-of-all-evil mantra). So only Baptist Southern Dems ever won, and even then, only after a Watergate or in a 3-person race when pure-negative campaigns won't work, like when Perot allowed Clinton to easily win twice). Meanwhile, Dems and GOP only cared about the middle-class which got HOLLOWED OUT for 45 years. Obama and Biden could only win due to the peaks of the Great Recession and Global Financial Panic or the worst Pandemic in a century and ensuing supply shortage recession.
The indexing of Social Security had nothing to do with Reagan. It was enacted in 1972 and took effect in 1975. The increases should have been conditional based on funds available, but it probably wasn't a consideration since the baby-boomers were still entering the workforce at that time.
Reagan resigned in August 1974! Indexing exposed Social Security as a "pay-go" program and NEVER a social "insurance." Worse yet, the index was inappropriate an much too high for recipients; a "market basket" based on the prices seniors buy (seniors have houses paid off, but the CPI was based heavily on housing prices, and seniors have kids all grown so no education expenses, etc.! But "funds available" was never a legal or fiscal issue, since we were now off the gold standard and could print money as fast as we wanted.
Of Course. Nixon wasn't at all ideological, total pragmatist, had a famous ENEMIES LIST, used CIA and FBI to spy on Dem, in a 3 year period was a Monetarist, Keynesian, and Wage-Price Control (like elitist Galbraith)! He proposed a negative income tax to counter Dem's Guarantee Annual Income plan in 1972 election. Watergate was a tiny part of clandestine, broad scheme of dirty tricks (such as the fake "Canuck Letter" that keep Muskie from winning nomination (his only real threat to reelection).
I think you have your boogiemen mixed up. Reagan wasn't elected until 1980. Nixon was more centrist, at least economically speaking. As an example, he also attempted wage-price controls in response to inflation.
Aside from this placing an upper bound on your age and a lower bound on mine, I agree with most of the rest of your reply.
Agreed, you are exactly right about both major political parties.Also known as the lesser of two evils, but there is a third evil at work here - lazy, uninformed, uneducated voters who seem to believe,from what they learned in school?!,that democracy can run on auto pilot. Humans are incredibly lazy creatures who will suffer under the devil they know rather than rise up,over throw the old system and put something better.
That's where we are in America today: our roof has been leaking for 250 years, but we kept putting buckets under the drips. Oh sure,we put a tarp on part of roof during the Civil War-,but a tarp is not a real fix.
Time to get rid of white supremacy and pay for a new roof.
That's why many of us academic and policy consulting economists became "Progressive" Democrats (now a majority of Congress, who refuse all PAC money and advocate SYSTEMIC change in our sexist, racist, and status quo public institutions, not "incrementalism" quickly reversed when GOP gets power). I managed (for free) two such candidates this century and put up great fights while being outspent 100 to 1 (the AVERAGE margin for most Dems vs GOP). Democracy requires constant nurturing and defense, not voter consumerism or purely economic self-interest crap that ex-Republicans on MS-NOW push 24-7. As head of practical, get-things-done environmental agencies and civic groups, I saw far too many NIMBY self-interest advocates posing as environmentalists! Too many, "they're all bums" rationalizers who's "cure" is to cut (not raise) pitiful politician salaries (so only the rich and corrupt will ever be able to run for office). And we need far more women TO RUN!
As an elderly person, I respectfully disagree. Oh sure, the ones, mostly men, who had 6 figure income while working can afford the cruise and the fancy retirement home, but I can't because I was a single mom who wasn't paid what I should have been paid while working. I never earned $5k plus each month while working, so I am lucky to get my $2k in social security now, but that won't get me into the fancy retirement home.
We need radical wealth disparity adjustments in America ASAP,or, just Roll guillotine today!
Most all wealth and economic power now in the hands of seniors. Poverty rates for seniors is ONE-FOURTH that for CHILDREN (who do not get to choose their fate -- income of their parents -- nor have 50 years of education/training and work/saving opportunities to determine their retirement income and pensions). Yet seniors NEVER MENTION THE CHILDREN in their blind self-defense. Plummeting birth rates (kids now unaffordable!) are emptying out Social Security funding (always based on a lie -- it's all funded by CURRENT WORKERS, i.e., "pay as we go"; rest of Social Security Trust Fund was drained dry by the illegal, war-of-choice invasion of Iraq that we refused to prevent!).
Are we ignoring the fact that "workers" and "retirees" are the same people at different ages? Should I, at 45, vote for lower taxes today if it means lower benefits for me and my spouse in 25 years? Seems short-sighted.
When we did a close look at this when I was at OMB, the disparities were even more striking when the analyses were per capita post tax. Elderly households sans children while non-elderly families include kids.
To what extent could this be addressed by reverting to the tax structure of the “good old days” of the 1950’s? What about if we dropped the Bush II and Trump tax cuts?
45 years of Reaganism not only led to record income inequality (worse than even Robber Baron days and worse than any industrialized nation, even Great Britain), but also a flip in income's age distribution. Partly due to indexing Social Security, already the most regressive public pension plan on Earth (Reverse Robin Hood: transfers income from working poor with low life expectancy to long-lived middle class elderly who need supplements least). At the same time, vanishing union power (Reagan's and corporate war on unions, reclassification of workers into temps, "associates," adjuncts, intern trainees, independent contractors who can't be organized), discriminated women and minority domination of wage-earners, migration to anti-union Sunbelt, gutting of worker protections, and U.S. shift from shortest to longest workweeks with fewest vacation day (while most nations have early retirement for heavy-labor workers!
Yeah, I always hated Reagan
But Dems losses in 5 out of 6 presidential elections caused Dems, to tack to the center-right (as if more voters would ever opt for Republican-lite over "principled", , real conservatives who'd never "sell out" -- i.e., never compromise their simplistic government-the-source-of-all-evil mantra). So only Baptist Southern Dems ever won, and even then, only after a Watergate or in a 3-person race when pure-negative campaigns won't work, like when Perot allowed Clinton to easily win twice). Meanwhile, Dems and GOP only cared about the middle-class which got HOLLOWED OUT for 45 years. Obama and Biden could only win due to the peaks of the Great Recession and Global Financial Panic or the worst Pandemic in a century and ensuing supply shortage recession.
The indexing of Social Security had nothing to do with Reagan. It was enacted in 1972 and took effect in 1975. The increases should have been conditional based on funds available, but it probably wasn't a consideration since the baby-boomers were still entering the workforce at that time.
Reagan resigned in August 1974! Indexing exposed Social Security as a "pay-go" program and NEVER a social "insurance." Worse yet, the index was inappropriate an much too high for recipients; a "market basket" based on the prices seniors buy (seniors have houses paid off, but the CPI was based heavily on housing prices, and seniors have kids all grown so no education expenses, etc.! But "funds available" was never a legal or fiscal issue, since we were now off the gold standard and could print money as fast as we wanted.
Also, the legislation that enabled indexing was bipartisan, if not unanimous.
Of Course. Nixon wasn't at all ideological, total pragmatist, had a famous ENEMIES LIST, used CIA and FBI to spy on Dem, in a 3 year period was a Monetarist, Keynesian, and Wage-Price Control (like elitist Galbraith)! He proposed a negative income tax to counter Dem's Guarantee Annual Income plan in 1972 election. Watergate was a tiny part of clandestine, broad scheme of dirty tricks (such as the fake "Canuck Letter" that keep Muskie from winning nomination (his only real threat to reelection).
I think you have your boogiemen mixed up. Reagan wasn't elected until 1980. Nixon was more centrist, at least economically speaking. As an example, he also attempted wage-price controls in response to inflation.
Aside from this placing an upper bound on your age and a lower bound on mine, I agree with most of the rest of your reply.
Agreed, you are exactly right about both major political parties.Also known as the lesser of two evils, but there is a third evil at work here - lazy, uninformed, uneducated voters who seem to believe,from what they learned in school?!,that democracy can run on auto pilot. Humans are incredibly lazy creatures who will suffer under the devil they know rather than rise up,over throw the old system and put something better.
That's where we are in America today: our roof has been leaking for 250 years, but we kept putting buckets under the drips. Oh sure,we put a tarp on part of roof during the Civil War-,but a tarp is not a real fix.
Time to get rid of white supremacy and pay for a new roof.
That's why many of us academic and policy consulting economists became "Progressive" Democrats (now a majority of Congress, who refuse all PAC money and advocate SYSTEMIC change in our sexist, racist, and status quo public institutions, not "incrementalism" quickly reversed when GOP gets power). I managed (for free) two such candidates this century and put up great fights while being outspent 100 to 1 (the AVERAGE margin for most Dems vs GOP). Democracy requires constant nurturing and defense, not voter consumerism or purely economic self-interest crap that ex-Republicans on MS-NOW push 24-7. As head of practical, get-things-done environmental agencies and civic groups, I saw far too many NIMBY self-interest advocates posing as environmentalists! Too many, "they're all bums" rationalizers who's "cure" is to cut (not raise) pitiful politician salaries (so only the rich and corrupt will ever be able to run for office). And we need far more women TO RUN!
Agreed, more women and everyday people, not the Rich
As an elderly person, I respectfully disagree. Oh sure, the ones, mostly men, who had 6 figure income while working can afford the cruise and the fancy retirement home, but I can't because I was a single mom who wasn't paid what I should have been paid while working. I never earned $5k plus each month while working, so I am lucky to get my $2k in social security now, but that won't get me into the fancy retirement home.
We need radical wealth disparity adjustments in America ASAP,or, just Roll guillotine today!
Most all wealth and economic power now in the hands of seniors. Poverty rates for seniors is ONE-FOURTH that for CHILDREN (who do not get to choose their fate -- income of their parents -- nor have 50 years of education/training and work/saving opportunities to determine their retirement income and pensions). Yet seniors NEVER MENTION THE CHILDREN in their blind self-defense. Plummeting birth rates (kids now unaffordable!) are emptying out Social Security funding (always based on a lie -- it's all funded by CURRENT WORKERS, i.e., "pay as we go"; rest of Social Security Trust Fund was drained dry by the illegal, war-of-choice invasion of Iraq that we refused to prevent!).
Are we ignoring the fact that "workers" and "retirees" are the same people at different ages? Should I, at 45, vote for lower taxes today if it means lower benefits for me and my spouse in 25 years? Seems short-sighted.
If you invest your tax savings you should be better off in the long run.
When we did a close look at this when I was at OMB, the disparities were even more striking when the analyses were per capita post tax. Elderly households sans children while non-elderly families include kids.
To what extent could this be addressed by reverting to the tax structure of the “good old days” of the 1950’s? What about if we dropped the Bush II and Trump tax cuts?
Reverting automatic COLAs should be more effective. Let Congress address benefits periodically like they did in the old days.
We the people didn't get a choice about the war in Iraq, or the others,come to think of it.
Of course. That generation holds all the assets.