Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Timothy Burke's avatar

The problem for anyone who has what they consider to be sensible advice about government policy is that in the present environment, sensible policy regardless of its political character is dead on arrival. No coherent policy guidance has a chance to influence what the federal government does and is effectively blocked from somewhere between 5-10 state legislatures as well. Trumpism is in this sense a fundamental prior that has to be reckoned with in order to imagine a government that is once again porous to policy analysis and advice. If any of us started writing sober and careful technical advice about what should be done in terms of environmental remediation to Atlantis once it it raised from the ocean floor, we'd rightly be seen as writing a kind of fiction considering that Atlantis doesn't exist and hasn't been raised. That's the situation we're in now, more or less--the government that considers a range of options, collects data, consults with stakeholders, methodically writes legislation, holds public hearings, etc. does not presently exist. It is as fictional as sunken Atlantis.

A more grounded parallel that I've seen for much of my career is well-meaning development economists and political scientists advising African states to adopt particular policies without acknowledging that the states they're advising completely lack the capacity to implement the policies in question and lack a leadership that has any interest in the common good within their own nations. At which point the policy analysis is just a sort of fiction, however salient it might be.

In that context, refocusing on MAGA and Trumpism as the central problem that must be solved before any other kind of thinking can be relevant again isn't political or partisan. It's just a material fact that stands in the way of any other governmental action. Nor is it just a passive obstacle: it is an existential threat, not the least because all the things that are covered by policy advice are going undone and unaddressed in the meantime.

Mark Soskin's avatar

This issue has long since evolved from "label" to "identity", the group you aspire to be part of, consider yourself a member of to emulate, admire, gain comfort, and obsess about. It's not just a label identifier. It's your very IDENTITY. You attend concerts, tailgating, or rallies more to hang with others who SHARE that identity. You are a Penn State fan, a Rolling Stone groupie, a MAGA fanatic of Trump. And you think you OWN them: demand Whitney to sing more Black, run the ball more, or deport more people.

9 more comments...

Ready for more?