In my writing, I usually try to avoid being pinned to any group label. Unlike so many public policy writers, I don’t claim that you should read me because I am a conservative, liberal, Republican, Democrat, Catholic, evangelical, Jewish, or, God forbid, an economist. I neither accept nor reject others’ writings because of group affiliation. I even find the labels “independent” or “moderate” to have limited informational value, since I’ve seen so many false proclamations of achievement when both political parties compromise to enact new special-interest giveaways and leave the bills to our children.
Most importantly, I respect you as my reader. I don’t want to use a group label to appeal to you. I know many of my readers, including extended family, have voted for both Republicans and Democrats, and for and against Trump. If I present my reasoning and information well, I hope you will read what I say, find it informative, and at times useful in thinking about ways we can move forward together.
That approach is not easy in the Trump era, given all the harm he has inflicted on so many, including my relations, colleagues, city, country, and foreign friends.
I am motivated to write this note in part because of a comment from Brad DeLong, one of the Substack authors I recommend. A Harvard-educated, Berkeley economist who thinks deeply about issues ranging from economic history and policy to artificial intelligence, he critiqued me a while ago for being too “two-sided.” In fairness to him—here I go, being two-sided—one of my best and most loyal friends, himself much more of a self-identified conservative, has made a similar claim for many years.
I’ll get to Brad and Trump in a minute. First, I want briefly to explain why I write the way I do, and you can decide whether I spend too much or too little time on Trump.
How My Background Influences My Approach
My approach to most discussions—I’m not claiming purity here or denying the validity of other approaches—likely stems from my religious, mathematical, and professional experiences.
When it comes to religion, I proudly claim to be a bit of a mutt, with Catholic, Jewish, and Southern Baptist grandparents; a Catholic father and a Presbyterian mother; some dear agnostic relatives; and a Muslim former exchange student who calls me “Dad.”
As an undergraduate math major, I’ve always focused on understanding and solving problems. Group or personal identity has never disqualified or qualified any of my colleagues from solving problems with me. I’m very uncomfortable in meetings where people first want to label themselves and others.
I also spent about 17 years early in my career working for the federal government as a soldier and, mainly, as a civil servant in the Treasury Department under both Democratic and Republican presidents. My greatest success in those years came from organizing and then coordinating the most comprehensive set of Treasury proposals for income tax reform in U.S. history. The subsequent bipartisan passage of the Tax Reform Act of 1986 (TRA86) was due in no small part to recognizing legitimate principles—neither Republican nor Democratic, neither conservative nor liberal, but basic public finance principles such as equal justice (equal treatment of equals), efficiency, and administrability. I still look back on that experience as a model that I believe can, perhaps must, be used to address many governing issues, including our extraordinary budget, tax, and spending mess.
Searching for common ground through shared principles has at times put me in the crosshairs of both political parties. For the better, I have been given exciting opportunities to address some of the most intractable problems and help forge consensus. In addition to my role in TRA86, for instance, I was the only person invited to testify on tax policy before the Simpson-Bowles Commission, which sought major fiscal reform. Some acknowledged that testimony as playing a key role in helping that group reach a majority (but not the necessary supermajority) consensus for budget reform.
Unfortunately, it has at times denied me access in a world where success often requires allegiance to, or at least not offending, one political party. I was the “Jim Kelly” (Kelly, a Buffalo Bills quarterback, lost the Super Bowl four times) among the finalists for Congressional Budget Office Director. People ranging from former Senator Kent Conrad (D, N.D., Chair of the Senate Budget Committee) to former Speaker of the House Paul Ryan (R, WI) told me they backed me “last time”—that is, when it was the other party’s choice.
The Trump Era
This brings me to the era of Trump, who, for the past few years, has succeeded in defining himself as “the alternative” to Democrats, other Republican factions, and to any media that does nothing but praise him. Populists who attain power try to label anyone who disagrees with them on any matter as “the other,” “fake,” or “unpatriotic.” As studies well document, the populist seeks to delegitimize systems of information, whether in science or journalism, and within or outside government, and thereby control and sole-source the nation’s story about itself.
This makes it hard to build common ground when every policy issue must be framed in binary terms, pro- or anti-MAGA.
If you’re young, you may never have experienced anything other than the extraordinary extent to which the information offered to you has increasingly been culled, marketed, and tailored to your group identities, not just by MAGA. You are constantly monitored by what some skeptics call “the Machine.”
Brad DeLong’s Complaint
So far, I have laid out a bit about why I write the way I do. Whereas my conservative friend has always been fiercely loyal, DeLong claimed he really didn’t want to listen to me unless, among other things, I called for Trump’s impeachment. In a specific piece on gerrymandering, he felt I had to attack Trump more directly as the culprit in norm-breaking. He deemed as inadequate my note that “Democrats feel they were merely responding to Republican gerrymandering efforts, promoted by President Trump,” when making their own disenfranchising and gerrymandering efforts.
So why don’t I spend more time attacking Trump in this and other columns? When I write columns critical of Trump’s disregard for standards or societal needs, such as “The Whimsical Presidency,” “Losing the Information Wars,” “Addressing Major Constitutional Issues,” “The President’s Nano Budget,” and “Taxes and Billionaires,” I am clearly critical. Yet my focus usually turns to the consequences of those actions and the underlying issues I believe we must address now and long after Trump’s tenure.
Consider also: Trump is like an abusive father who constantly demands attention and divides his family into two camps, those who defend him and those who oppose him. Whether you or I attack or defend him personally, he gets the attention he wants.
Worse, when I give him too much attention in my articles, it can trigger a knee-jerk reaction among some readers. I don’t know who most of you voted for, which groups you belong to, or how much those identities define you or help you make sense of the world. Some people decide whether to read an article based on how much it reinforces their belief systems and group identities. Again, I’m not claiming purity; I’m tempted to do the same. Still, I don’t want you to agree with or reject my contribution based on group identification.
In the article Brad attacked, I was trying to appeal to a mix of Republican and Democratic governors to unite and stop this downward spiral that disenfranchises many parts of the population. Would saying, “Impeach Trump!” have helped my appeal for Governors Abbot (TX) and Newsom (CA) to mutually agree to re-enfranchise Democrats in Texas and Republicans in California? I don’t think so.
Furthermore, most of my work seeks to engage you in thinking about a post-Trump, post-Biden, post-early-21st-century world. Many of the problems I address, such as the abandonment of the working class and the young, the unsustainability of many programs, and the inability to redirect resources to modern needs and opportunities, have been festering for decades.
A More Personal Notes
My family and I are extremely angry about the destruction caused by Trump and his protégés. He ended the very productive careers of many people close to my wife and me. A daughter working on civil rights in the Justice Department left over the Department’s refusal to properly examine deaths at the hands of ICE in places like Minneapolis, abuse in ICE detention facilities, and other violations of federal law. A cousin’s daughter lost a productive career as the U.S. abandoned its USAID support systems, leading to hundreds of thousands of deaths and the destruction of the systems of soft power, trust, and goodwill across the world. In his attempt to dismantle government information systems and agencies, he has fired or forced others I know to quit through a variety of tactics, including relocating their offices far from their current sites. His attacks on research led to job losses for many people I worked with. The attack on people who devote their lives to serving the public likely has made young people wary of civil service, with ramifications for decades to come.
Moreover, several of his major advisors and supporters over the years have peddled conspiracy theories, including denying that my former wife was murdered on September 11, 2001. One of Trump’s continuing political strategies is to appeal to conspiracy theorists, often by retweeting their outrageous posts. I typically do not mention these personal issues in my columns because they give me little or no authority on the issue I am discussing with you. However, you are entitled to know these facts about me.
***
Now you know a bit more about why I tend to write the way I do. I certainly don’t claim to strike the right balance. Still, I hope you’ll stick with me and even recommend my articles to others. Either way, you now know better what you’re getting and why.




The problem for anyone who has what they consider to be sensible advice about government policy is that in the present environment, sensible policy regardless of its political character is dead on arrival. No coherent policy guidance has a chance to influence what the federal government does and is effectively blocked from somewhere between 5-10 state legislatures as well. Trumpism is in this sense a fundamental prior that has to be reckoned with in order to imagine a government that is once again porous to policy analysis and advice. If any of us started writing sober and careful technical advice about what should be done in terms of environmental remediation to Atlantis once it it raised from the ocean floor, we'd rightly be seen as writing a kind of fiction considering that Atlantis doesn't exist and hasn't been raised. That's the situation we're in now, more or less--the government that considers a range of options, collects data, consults with stakeholders, methodically writes legislation, holds public hearings, etc. does not presently exist. It is as fictional as sunken Atlantis.
A more grounded parallel that I've seen for much of my career is well-meaning development economists and political scientists advising African states to adopt particular policies without acknowledging that the states they're advising completely lack the capacity to implement the policies in question and lack a leadership that has any interest in the common good within their own nations. At which point the policy analysis is just a sort of fiction, however salient it might be.
In that context, refocusing on MAGA and Trumpism as the central problem that must be solved before any other kind of thinking can be relevant again isn't political or partisan. It's just a material fact that stands in the way of any other governmental action. Nor is it just a passive obstacle: it is an existential threat, not the least because all the things that are covered by policy advice are going undone and unaddressed in the meantime.
This issue has long since evolved from "label" to "identity", the group you aspire to be part of, consider yourself a member of to emulate, admire, gain comfort, and obsess about. It's not just a label identifier. It's your very IDENTITY. You attend concerts, tailgating, or rallies more to hang with others who SHARE that identity. You are a Penn State fan, a Rolling Stone groupie, a MAGA fanatic of Trump. And you think you OWN them: demand Whitney to sing more Black, run the ball more, or deport more people.